How AI Killed the Click … And What Brands Must Do Now

Posted on by
Contents show
How AI Killed the Click ... And What Brands Must Do Now
How AI Killed the Click … And What Brands Must Do Now

The way people search for things online has quietly changed. And most brands are only just waking up to it.

How AI Killed the Click … And What Brands Must Do Now

There's a shift happening in the background of every marketing meeting right now, and it's making some very powerful people nervous. We're talking about brand executives at companies like Airbnb and Expedia … people who run billion-dollar advertising budgets … suddenly having to answer uncomfortable questions from analysts on earnings calls. Questions about whether their search traffic is going to survive the AI era.

That's not a small thing. When the conversation moves from marketing departments into boardrooms, you know something real is happening.

So what exactly is going on? And what does it mean for any brand trying to reach people online?

Let's get into it.

What Is Zero-Click Search and Why Should Anyone Care?

To understand what's changing, you need to understand how search used to work … and how it works now.

The old version of Google search was pretty simple. You type in a question, Google shows you a list of websites, you click one, you read it. That click was the whole point. It's how websites got visitors. It's how brands got potential customers to land on their pages. It's how publishers made money from ads.

Now think about what happens when you search for something like “best hotel in Barcelona for a couple” today. Before you even see a list of websites, Google drops a big AI-generated summary right at the top of the page. It tells you the best hotels, what makes each one special, and what you should consider when booking. It answers your question completely.

And so you read it, get your answer, and leave. Without clicking anything.

That's zero-click search. The user got what they needed without visiting a single website.

This has been slowly building for years … Google started showing quick answer boxes and featured snippets a long time ago. But with the rollout of AI Overviews (formerly called Search Generative Experience), the scale of this shift has gone from noticeable to genuinely alarming for brands.

Every time someone's question gets answered inside Google's AI summary, that's one fewer click that might have gone to a brand's website, a publisher's article, or a retailer's product page.

The Numbers That Are Making Executives Sweat

Here's where it gets real. According to data from media agency Wpromote's Polaris IQ platform, the average advertiser saw their organic search traffic drop 12% between Q3 and Q4 of 2025 alone.

That's not a blip. That's a clear directional signal.

The drops weren't evenly spread across all industries either. Publishing companies, telecom brands, and healthcare businesses took the biggest hits. E-commerce brands saw smaller declines … but they still saw declines.

Daniel Moreno, a senior SEO and GEO consultant at Dept UK, put it plainly: it's almost a given that every search console account is showing some level of drop in clicks and impressions. And it doesn't matter if you're a small brand or a massive one. The trend is cutting across the board.

Scott Hendler, associate director of paid search at media agency Ars X Machina, confirmed that this is no longer a niche conversation. Whether clients are spotting it in their own data or stumbling across industry coverage, zero-click search has come up across every single client conversation. There's real concern in the room.

What started as an SEO niche worry has officially become a business problem.

Why the Traffic Drop Isn't (Necessarily) a Revenue Disaster

Okay, so organic traffic is falling. That sounds catastrophic. But here's the part that's actually a bit reassuring … and a lot more interesting.

Sales and conversions are, in many cases, holding steady even as traffic numbers fall.

Charlie Marchant, CEO of SEO firm ExposureNinja, describes this as a “general trend” playing out across categories. When brands dig into their data, they're finding that the traffic they're losing isn't necessarily the traffic that was going to buy anything.

Think about it this way. If you search “what causes jet lag” and Google gives you a full answer at the top of the page, you read it and leave. You were never going to buy anything. You were just curious. That lost click doesn't cost a brand any revenue.

The people who actually have their credit card ready … who are actively trying to book a flight, buy a product, or sign up for a service … those people still click through. They still go to the website to complete the transaction. They have specific intent, and an AI summary isn't going to fully satisfy that intent. They need to interact with the actual product, compare prices, enter their details.

Edward ‘Teddie' Cowell, global VP of SEO at WPP Media, described it like this: more of the discovery and evaluation stage is now happening inside AI summaries, but people still want to actually buy things. They still go into websites to transact.

Brian Chesky, CEO of Airbnb, went one step further during an earnings call and shared something that's becoming a pattern across the industry. Traffic coming from AI chatbots like ChatGPT is converting at a higher rate than traffic coming from traditional Google search.

Read that again.

People who arrive at Airbnb after a conversation with an AI tool are more likely to book than people who come from clicking a regular Google result. Why? Because by the time an AI has walked them through options and they've asked follow-up questions and narrowed things down, they're more ready to commit. The consideration phase already happened inside the chatbot.

Ariane Gorin, CEO of Expedia, shared a similar outlook. AI search creates more context in the query … someone isn't just searching “hotels Barcelona,” they might tell the AI “I'm planning a romantic anniversary trip for early April with a budget of around $200 per night.” That context makes it way easier to serve relevant results and convert that person when they land on the platform.

So the picture is nuanced. Traffic is down. But the quality of remaining traffic might actually be going up. The casual window shoppers are being filtered out by AI. The serious buyers are still coming through.

The Catch: You Still Have to Earn Your Spot in the AI Summary

Here's where brands need to pay close attention.

If AI tools are increasingly the gatekeepers … deciding which brands get mentioned, which products get recommended, and which answers get surfaced … then being visible inside those AI summaries is becoming just as important as ranking on page one of Google used to be.

And that visibility doesn't come automatically. You have to earn it.

Moreno put it directly: in the past, many brands didn't invest much thought or budget into SEO. It was something they knew they probably should care about but pushed down the priority list. Now, they've been forced to actually reckon with it. The AI era has made search optimization not optional anymore.

This has given rise to what's being called a new search playbook. It's built on a foundation of organic content optimization, but it reaches further than traditional SEO ever did.

What the New Search Playbook Actually Looks Like

The core insight is this: AI models and AI-powered search features like Google's Overviews don't just pull in any old content. They pull in content that is clear, authoritative, specific, and structured in a way that answers real questions.

Vague, keyword-stuffed web pages that were written to game old-school SEO rankings don't work in this environment. What works is content that actually helps people … content that sounds like it was written by someone who genuinely knows what they're talking about.

Some of the shifts brands and their agencies are making right now include:

1. Shifting toward longer, conversational keyword targeting

As users lean into AI-powered search features, their queries are getting longer and more conversational. Instead of typing “Barcelona hotel,” someone might type “What's a good boutique hotel in Barcelona's Gothic Quarter for a couple on a honeymoon budget?” into the Google search bar and let AI Overview handle it.

Brands are now bidding against these longer, more conversational keyword strings in paid search because that's where potential customers actually are. Hendler at Ars X Machina described it as fighting for prime real estate … and the prime real estate has shifted.

2. Optimizing content to appear inside AI summaries

This is sometimes called GEO … Generative Engine Optimization … and it's becoming a serious discipline alongside traditional SEO. The goal is to create content that AI tools will want to pull from when compiling their summaries.

That means writing content that directly and concisely answers specific questions. It means establishing authority in a particular subject area. It means making sure your brand is mentioned and cited by credible third-party sources, because AI tools often source from reviews, news articles, and established publications.

3. Rethinking what “success” looks like in search

Historically, the number one metric for search performance was traffic … how many people clicked through to your site. That metric is becoming less reliable as a standalone indicator of health.

Brands are starting to track things like brand mention frequency inside AI-generated answers, conversion rate from AI-referred traffic, and overall revenue rather than obsessing purely over click numbers. The goal is staying visible in the new environment, even if the visibility doesn't always look like a traditional website visit.

The Paid Search Question: Where Does Ad Spend Go from Here?

One of the biggest open questions in the industry right now is what happens to paid search spending.

Right now, Google pulls ads into its AI Overviews and AI Mode features from broad match campaigns … meaning advertisers don't directly buy placement inside those AI summaries. They run regular campaigns and Google decides whether to pull from them.

This creates a real problem for brands that want to be present in AI-generated search experiences. There's no deliberate way to buy that placement yet. You can't just say “I want my ad inside the AI Overview for this query” and make it happen. You have to run a broader campaign and hope Google selects your ad.

Dez Muserelli, director of paid search at Attention Arc, described the situation with a great analogy: it's like buying the whole charcuterie board just to get the olives. You're spending across the whole campaign just to maybe end up in the one placement that actually matters.

Google has indicated that its AI Max for Search product is likely to become the main vehicle for advertising inside AI-powered experiences. But currently, there's no guarantee that a brand's ad will be selected to appear in Overviews or AI Mode, which means going all-in on that format doesn't yet make financial sense.

What Advertisers Are Actually Doing With Budget Right Now

Rather than cutting spend or dramatically boosting it, most brands are doing something more strategic … they're moving money around.

The goal is to make sure spend is concentrated in the areas where it's most likely to reach users at a real decision point. That means:

  • Shifting more budget toward longer-tail, high-intent search queries
  • Maintaining organic SEO investment to stay visible in AI-generated summaries
  • Watching closely as Google expands ad placement options inside AI features
  • Tracking AI referral traffic as a separate channel to understand its conversion behavior

The brands that are taking this seriously are the ones treating AI search as a distinct channel that needs its own strategy … not just an extension of what worked in traditional Google search.

What Happens When AI Mode Ads Go Mainstream?

Everyone in the industry is watching and waiting for the moment when Google opens up guaranteed ad placements inside AI Mode and Overviews at scale.

When that happens, the entire game changes again. Brands that have been building their organic presence and content authority inside these AI systems will be well-positioned to amplify that presence with paid spend. Brands that ignored it will be starting from scratch … and potentially paying premium prices to enter an environment where their competitors have already built credibility.

There's also a broader question about what the ad units will look like inside conversational AI search. Traditional display ads and text links feel out of place when someone is having a back-and-forth conversation with an AI. The ad formats that work in this environment will likely need to feel more native, more contextually relevant, and less interruptive.

Some experts think this could actually be a positive moment for brand advertising … if done well. Conversational AI search surfaces users with high intent and specific context. An ad that matches that context precisely could perform extremely well. The challenge is building the infrastructure to serve those ads at scale, and building consumer trust in a format that doesn't yet feel familiar.

What This Means If You're a Brand Right Now

Let's bring this down to earth.

If you're a brand, a marketing team, or anyone responsible for driving traffic and revenue from search, here's the honest summary of where things stand:

The traffic decline is real and will likely continue. Google's AI Overviews are expanding. More queries will get answered without a click. This is the direction things are moving in, and hoping it reverses isn't a strategy.

Your revenue isn't doomed. The traffic you're losing is largely composed of low-intent, early-stage users who weren't going to buy anything imminently. The serious buyers are still clicking through. And users arriving from AI tools like ChatGPT are converting at high rates.

Being mentioned inside AI summaries matters now. If your brand isn't being cited or recommended when people ask AI tools about your category, you're invisible to a growing segment of potential customers. Getting into those summaries requires the kind of high-quality, genuinely helpful, authoritative content that earns it.

Your paid search strategy needs a rethink. Bidding against the same keywords you've always used won't reach users the same way. Longer, more conversational queries are where intent is being expressed. And you need to be watching closely for when guaranteed placements inside AI experiences become available, because that will be a significant moment.

SEO and content have moved from optional to urgent. The brands that were cavalier about search optimization are now scrambling. The brands that invested steadily in quality content and genuine authority are finding that those assets translate well into the AI search era.

The Bigger Picture: Search Has Always Changed, and Brands Have Always Adapted

It's worth stepping back for a moment and remembering that search has always changed.

When Google first launched, it upended how people found information on the internet. When mobile search took off, brands had to rethink everything about how their sites worked. When voice search emerged, there was a wave of prediction and panic about what it would mean for typed queries. Featured snippets caused their own version of the current anxiety about zero-click results.

Each time, the landscape shifted. Each time, the brands that paid attention and adapted early found advantage. The brands that waited for certainty before moving ended up behind.

This moment with AI feels bigger than those previous shifts, and honestly, it probably is. The change to search behavior is more fundamental. The gatekeeping role of AI tools is more pronounced. The potential for AI to short-circuit the traditional path from discovery to purchase is real.

But the underlying truth hasn't changed. People still want things. They still research before buying. They still want to find brands that solve their problems. The path they take to get there is just different now.

The brands that will thrive are the ones that show up authentically and helpfully wherever people are looking … whether that's a traditional search results page, an AI-generated summary, a chatbot conversation, or something we haven't thought of yet.

The GEO Era Is Just Getting Started

There's a growing discipline called Generative Engine Optimization … GEO for short … and it's quickly becoming as important as traditional SEO ever was.

GEO is the practice of optimizing your content and brand presence to appear prominently inside AI-generated responses. It draws on some of the same principles as SEO (be authoritative, be relevant, structure your content clearly) but it also requires thinking about how AI models evaluate and synthesize information differently from how a search engine ranks pages.

Some of the emerging principles of GEO include:

Building genuine expertise signals. AI models are getting better at distinguishing between content that's genuinely written by people who know their stuff versus content that's been manufactured to rank. Real expertise … demonstrated through depth, specificity, and accuracy … matters more than ever.

Getting mentioned in third-party sources. If reputable publications, review platforms, and industry sources are talking about your brand positively, AI tools are more likely to reference you when compiling summaries. PR and media relations are having something of a renaissance as a result.

Structuring content to answer specific questions. Content that's organized around actual questions people ask … and that answers those questions directly and clearly … gets pulled into AI summaries more reliably than content that's vague or promotional.

Being present across multiple touchpoints. If your brand is visible on Reddit threads, YouTube reviews, news articles, industry forums, and your own well-optimized website, that distributed presence makes you a stronger signal for AI tools to pick up on.

None of this is about gaming the system. The brands that try to shortcut their way into AI visibility with low-quality, manufactured content will find that it doesn't work. The brands that genuinely invest in being helpful, accurate, and present across the web will find that the AI era rewards them.

A Closing Thought

The zero-click era isn't coming. It's already here.

The brands still waiting to fully process what that means are already behind. But the encouraging thing is that the fundamentals of what makes a brand trustworthy and worth recommending haven't changed. Quality content. Genuine expertise. A product or service that actually delivers. A presence that people recognize and trust.

What's changed is where that trust gets built and how it gets found. The building is happening more and more inside AI conversations. The finding is happening through recommendations that surface in responses, not just links that appear in results.

The brands that understand this shift and adapt to it aren't just surviving zero-click search. They're building the kind of brand authority that matters regardless of how search changes next.

And it will change again. Count on it.

When it does, the brands that treated this moment as a signal … rather than a crisis … will be the ones that are ready.

More Posts:
Subscription Form