The Ultimate Guide to Tracking Brand Visibility Across AI Search Platforms

Posted on November 29, 2024November 29, 2024 by Mark Harrell

Contents show

The AI Search Revolution: A New Frontier for Brands

The world of search is changing fast. Gone are the days when Google was the only game in town. Now, AI-powered search tools are shaking things up. These new players are changing how people find information and shop online. For brands, this means rethinking how they stay visible in search results.

Why AI Search Matters

AI search tools like ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Microsoft's Copilot are gaining traction. They're not just answering questions – they're helping people make decisions, including what to buy. This shift is huge for brands. If you're not showing up in AI search results, you might be missing out on a growing chunk of potential customers.

The Challenge for Marketers

Here's the tricky part: AI search doesn't work like traditional search engines. You can't just optimize for keywords and call it a day. These tools use natural language and pull information from all over the web. This means brands need new ways to track and improve their visibility.

Understanding the AI Search Landscape

Key Players in AI Search

ChatGPT: OpenAI's chatbot that's become a go-to for many users.
Perplexity: A search engine that provides detailed, sourced answers.
Microsoft Copilot: Integrated into Bing and other Microsoft products.
Google's AI Features: Including AI Overviews and AI Shopping tools.

How AI Search is Different

AI search tools don't just list links. They generate answers, recommend products, and even help with complex tasks. This changes the game for brands in a few key ways:

Visibility isn't just about ranking #1 anymore.
Brand mentions in AI-generated content become crucial.
The sources AI tools cite can make or break your visibility.

The Impact on Consumer Behavior

Shopping in the AI Era

Remember when Black Friday meant crowded malls and long lines? AI is changing that. Now, people can get personalized gift ideas without leaving their couch. AI tools can factor in budgets, interests, and trends to suggest the perfect presents.

For brands, this means adapting to a new kind of shopper – one who relies on AI for recommendations and research.

The Opportunity for Brands

While this shift might seem daunting, it's also a huge opportunity. Brands that figure out how to shine in AI search results can connect with customers in powerful new ways. Imagine being the top recommendation when someone asks an AI for gift ideas in your product category. That's the potential we're talking about.

Tracking Brand Visibility in AI Search

The Old Ways Don't Work

Traditional SEO metrics like keyword rankings don't tell the whole story in AI search. These tools don't have a fixed “first page” of results. Instead, they generate unique responses for each query.

New Approaches to Visibility Tracking

Enter topic-based tracking. Instead of focusing on specific keywords, this method looks at how often your brand is mentioned across a range of related topics. Tools like Profound are leading the charge in this area.

Here's how it works:

Define key topics relevant to your brand and industry.
Use AI tracking tools to generate multiple prompts around these topics.
Analyze how often your brand is mentioned in the AI-generated responses.
Track changes in your brand's visibility over time.

This approach gives you a bird's-eye view of your brand's performance in AI search, even if you can't track every possible query.

Leveraging Topic Clusters for AI Search Success

What Are Topic Clusters?

Topic clusters are groups of related content that cover a subject thoroughly. They've been an SEO staple for years, but they're even more important for AI search.

Why Topic Clusters Matter for AI Search

AI search tools love comprehensive, authoritative content. By creating topic clusters, you're essentially building a web of information that AI can draw from. This increases the chances of your brand being cited as a source.

How to Build Effective Topic Clusters

Identify core topics relevant to your brand and audience.
Create a pillar page that broadly covers the main topic.
Develop multiple subtopic pages that link back to the pillar.
Ensure your content is thorough, accurate, and up-to-date.

Tools like Semrush, Ahrefs, or Moz can help you identify potential topics and subtopics to target.

Case Study: Tracking Toy Brand Visibility During Black Friday

To see these strategies in action, let's look at a real-world example. We'll focus on the toy industry during the competitive Black Friday shopping season.

The Setup

We chose to track major toy brands like Fisher-Price and Melissa & Doug across various AI search platforms. Here's how we did it:

Used SparkToro to generate a list of 50 toy-related topics.
Employed Profound to create and track prompts for each topic across ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Copilot.
Collected data on brand mentions, visibility scores, and citation trends over a week.

Key Findings

Fisher-Price dominated in 6 out of 9 key topics.
Brand visibility fluctuated daily, showing the dynamic nature of AI search.
Certain publications, like Tinybeans, were cited far more often than brand websites.
Seasonal relevance (e.g., Black Friday deals) significantly impacted citation trends.

Actionable Insights

Focus on building relationships with frequently cited publications.
Create content that aligns with seasonal trends and shopping behaviors.
Monitor visibility across multiple AI platforms, as performance can vary.

The Power of Digital PR in AI Search

Why Third-Party Content Matters

One surprising finding from our case study was how often AI tools cited third-party content over brand websites. This highlights the importance of digital PR in the AI search landscape.

Strategies for Digital PR Success

Target High-Impact Publications: Identify which sites are frequently cited by AI tools in your industry. In our toy example, Tinybeans was a clear leader.
Build Relationships: Reach out to key publishers and look for partnership opportunities. This could include guest posts, product reviews, or collaborative content.
Create Citeable Content: Develop resources that publishers will want to reference. This could include original research, comprehensive guides, or expert insights.
Stay on Top of Trends: AI tools favor fresh, relevant content. Keep your PR efforts aligned with current trends and seasonal topics.

The Double-Edged Sword of AI Search PR

The good news is that effective PR can lead to quick gains in AI search visibility. Unlike traditional SEO, where it can take months to see results, a well-placed mention can immediately boost your presence in AI-generated responses.

However, this visibility can be volatile. A competitor's PR push or changes in the AI's algorithm could quickly alter the landscape. This means ongoing monitoring and adaptation are crucial.

Building an Agile AI Search Team

The Need for a Dedicated Approach

As AI search continues to evolve, brands need a focused strategy to stay ahead. This means creating a team that can monitor, analyze, and respond to changes in the AI search landscape.

Key Components of an AI Search Team

Data Analysts: To track and interpret visibility trends across AI platforms.
Content Strategists: To develop topic clusters and align content with AI search trends.
Digital PR Specialists: To build relationships with key publishers and secure valuable mentions.
SEO Experts: To ensure your content is discoverable by both traditional search engines and AI tools.
AI Specialists: To understand the nuances of different AI platforms and how they process information.

Tools and Processes

Equip your team with the right tools:

AI Visibility Tracking: Tools like Profound for monitoring brand mentions across AI platforms.
Topic Research: SEO tools like Semrush or Ahrefs for identifying relevant topics and subtopics.
Content Management: Systems that allow for quick updates and content deployment.
Analytics: To track the impact of AI search visibility on overall traffic and conversions.

Fostering Agility

The key to success in AI search is adaptability. Your team should:

Hold regular strategy sessions to discuss AI search trends and performance.
Implement rapid testing and learning cycles for content and PR strategies.
Stay informed about updates to major AI platforms and adjust tactics accordingly.
Collaborate closely with other marketing teams to ensure a unified approach.

Practical Steps for Boosting AI Search Visibility

Now that we've covered the landscape and strategies, let's break down some concrete steps you can take to improve your brand's visibility in AI search results.

1. Conduct an AI Search Audit

Start by assessing your current performance:

Use tools like Profound to track your brand mentions across AI platforms.
Analyze which topics and queries your brand appears for most frequently.
Identify gaps where your brand is underrepresented in AI search results.

2. Develop a Topic Cluster Strategy

Based on your audit:

Identify 5-10 core topics central to your brand and industry.
Create comprehensive pillar pages for each core topic.
Develop a network of subtopic pages that link back to the pillars.
Ensure your content is thorough, accurate, and regularly updated.

3. Optimize for Natural Language

AI search often uses conversational queries. Adapt your content accordingly:

Include question-and-answer sections in your content.
Use natural, conversational language in your writing.
Address common pain points and queries your audience might have.

4. Leverage Structured Data

While AI doesn't rely solely on structured data, it can help:

Implement schema markup on your website to clearly define entities and relationships.
Use FAQ schema to increase the chances of your content being used for direct answers.

5. Focus on E-A-T (Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trustworthiness)

AI tools prioritize credible sources:

Showcase author expertise with detailed bios and credentials.
Cite reputable sources and include original research when possible.
Keep your content up-to-date, especially for time-sensitive topics.

6. Develop a Strategic Digital PR Plan

Based on your AI search audit:

Identify the top publications and websites cited in your industry.
Develop relationships with key journalists and content creators.
Create newsworthy content that aligns with your core topics.
Aim for a mix of product mentions, expert quotes, and full-length features.

7. Monitor and Adapt Regularly

Set up a system for ongoing tracking and optimization:

Use AI visibility tools to track your performance weekly.
Analyze which content and PR efforts are driving the most AI search mentions.
Be prepared to pivot quickly based on changes in AI search trends or algorithm updates.

8. Experiment with AI-Generated Content

While ensuring human oversight:

Use AI writing tools to generate initial drafts or content ideas.
Experiment with different content formats that AI seems to favor.
Always edit and fact-check AI-generated content before publishing.

9. Align with User Intent

Understanding why people use AI search is crucial:

Create content that directly addresses common user queries in your industry.
Provide clear, concise answers that AI tools can easily extract and present.
Consider the full user journey and create content for each stage, from awareness to purchase.

10. Build Brand Authority Beyond Your Website

AI tools often cite authoritative off-site content:

Contribute guest posts to reputable industry publications.
Participate in podcasts, webinars, and conferences to increase your digital footprint.
Maintain active, informative social media profiles that AI might reference.

The Future of AI Search and Brand Visibility

As we look ahead, it's clear that AI search will continue to evolve and shape how people find information and make decisions. Here are some trends and predictions to keep in mind:

Increased Personalization

AI search tools will likely become even more personalized, taking into account a user's history, preferences, and context. Brands will need to think about how to remain visible across different user segments.

Multi-Modal Search

The integration of image and voice search with AI is on the horizon. Brands should prepare by optimizing visual content and considering how their brand sounds in voice search results.

AI-to-AI Interactions

As users employ AI assistants for more tasks, we might see scenarios where AI tools interact with each other. This could create new challenges and opportunities for brand visibility.

Ethical and Transparency Concerns

As AI search becomes more prevalent, there will likely be increased scrutiny on how these tools source and present information. Brands that prioritize transparency and ethical practices may gain an advantage.

The Rise of Niche AI Tools

While general-purpose AI search tools will continue to grow, we may also see the emergence of industry-specific AI assistants. Brands should keep an eye out for AI tools tailored to their specific market.

Conclusion: Embracing the AI Search Revolution

The rise of AI search represents both a challenge and an opportunity for brands. Those who adapt quickly and thoughtfully can gain a significant edge in this new landscape. Here are the key takeaways:

AI search is here to stay. It's not just a trend, but a fundamental shift in how people find information and make decisions.
Traditional SEO metrics aren't enough. Brands need new ways to track and improve their visibility in AI-generated results.
Topic authority trumps keyword optimization. Creating comprehensive, authoritative content around key topics is crucial for AI search success.
Digital PR is more important than ever. Building relationships with frequently cited publications can significantly boost your AI search presence.
Agility is key. The AI search landscape is dynamic, requiring brands to continuously monitor, learn, and adapt their strategies.
It's still early days. Brands that invest in understanding and optimizing for AI search now have the opportunity to establish a strong position as this technology continues to evolve.

By embracing these principles and staying committed to providing value to your audience, you can ensure that your brand remains visible and relevant in the age of AI search. The future of search is here – it's time to adapt and thrive.